Part V: Hidden Identities: Intergenerational Trauma and the Nose Job



“Was I depressive and anxious by genetic design or neurotic as a descendent of Holocaust survivors or just a difficult child? Was I socially isolated, on some level, because I looked ethnic, immigranty, Jewish, or did I suffer from some kind of body dysmorphia? Or did I really just have an ugly face—a contingency that would make any childhood difficult?” wrote Naomi Lewis, a Calgary-based fiction and non-fiction writer, in reflecting on her nose job through her 2014 essay, “A Bridge Too Far: The story of my big Jewish nose.” 


Lewis was fourteen at the time of her rhinoplasty, and for the next 20+ years following it, was never quite sure why she continued to grapple with the event of her surgery: “It was always kind of the one thing in my life that I didn't think about without getting really upset…And I didn't know why… The therapist I went to was like, ‘This was like a Big ‘T’ trauma in your life.’


“A Bridge Too Far” served not only as an exploration of how nose jobs shape Jewish family histories, but as a way for Lewis to find some closure. The piece consisted of testimonies with her living relatives, an analytical look at her family’s history with Judaism, as well as research on the psychology and cultural meaning of the “Jewish nose.”


Despite her father’s side of the family having a rich Jewish history, the conversation of their religion wasn’t much of a conversation in Lewis’ household, which she infers to be a result of inter-generational Holocaust anxiety, as both her paternal grandmother and grandfather were survivors: “…they were very anxious and depressed [...] My dad really associated that with being Jewish. So when he met my mom, I think there's this thing of, the way to not feel bad is to just not be Jewish anymore.” This made it all the more disorienting  for Lewis when her grandmother encouraged her to get her nose done, thus identifying her as an Other. “She was alarmed by how Jewish I looked,” Lewis recalled,  “and I hadn't really understood that at all because I didn't understand the context.”


Unfortunately, this phenomenon isn’t one that is unique to Lewis. It has been proven that intergenerational trauma is common among the offspring of Holocaust survivors. A 2016 study conducted by researchers at Mount Sinai found that descendants of Holocaust survivors are more prone to stress disorders than their counterparts. Lewis’ isolation from her Jewish heritage, then was not to intentionally harm her, but was likely a trauma response. Her procedure, though not her own decision, was imposed on her in an attempt to protect her and heal the damaged psyche of her lineage. This notion of “healing the psyche” through aesthetic alteration is explored  by Sander Gilman in his book Creating Beauty to Cure the Soul. In this book, he describes multiple instances in which plastic surgery improved the livelihood of the patients. In talking about the nose, he wrote: “The very mirror of [the Jew’s] psyche was the result of the form of his nose.” 


With the nose so closely tied to Jewish identity, and Jewish identity being linked with hardship and pain, it is no wonder that some people undergo nose jobs to heal psychic pain from the Holocaust. However, no matter the physical alteration, the Jew will always be a Jew: “The Jew remains a Jew even when disguised.”


But surgery isn’t the only path to healing. Since “A Bridge Too Far,” Naomi Lewis has found comfort through familiarizing herself with her Jewish identity, and has since written a novel about her journey, titled Tiny Lights for Travellers. Lewis found comfort in her faith through writing, and has finally moved on from the surgical trauma that has plagued her as an adult.


“All of [it] was just extremely validating on a personal and cultural and historical level…Even though I'm not always sure that writing about stuff is cathartic in the way that people claim it is, I haven't really thought about it since…After that, I was like, ‘Who cares?’”