Part VI: Skin Off My Nose: The Jewish Nose and Rhinoplasty in the Digital Age



In 2018, reports showed that rhinoplasty rates in the U.S. had dropped 43% since the year 2000. But by 2020, that difference had narrowed to just 9%. How did such a dramatic shift happen in just two years?  


This shift aligns with the growth of one of the most dominating platforms in the world right now–TikTok. With 347 million users in 2018, the platform saw remarkable growth of 58.6% in the following two years, surpassing one billion.


Since its launch, TikTok has become a huge platform for creators to share and discuss beauty tips. It was reported to have been one of the top five categories in video creation in 2023, as well as driving $31.7 billion in cosmetics sales the same year. 


Nearly 300,000 videos have been uploaded using a filter bluntly titled, “BIG NOSE.” Users typically participate in a trend  in which the subject compares their face with a comically large, hooked and down-turned nose to their real life features once the filter is removed. “Try this filter and you will love your nose,” reads the text on one user’s video. “This filter makes me reconsider getting a nose job,” reads another.


While filters that promote natural beauty are valuable, the “BIG NOSE” filter reflects the same stereotypes that one can observe in Jewish caricatures–and worse, oftentimes resemble real noses. Carly Mandell, 21, says, “[they] bug me because you can't really tell the difference with my nose versus a friend with a smaller nose using the filter.” 


Over the past few years, filters have become a driving factor in those seeking cosmetic procedures. Plastic surgeons report  that patients often  reference TikTok or Snapchat filters in their consultations. According to a survey conducted in 2024, “86.6% of [plastic surgeon] respondents reported observing negative effects on patients due to their reliance on social media filters.” In this same survey, 74% of surgeons reported refusing  requests based on unrealistic sample photos of their subjects using filters. Additionally, a study conducted at Boston University observed a link between social media usage and cosmetic procedures. An uptick in screen time during the pandemic led to a higher rate of patients seeking plastic surgery post-pandemic. 


Why is this happening?


In short, we were not meant to be seeing ourselves as often as we do. In a DAZED article about this phenomenon, therapist Sally Baker states: “‘We become attuned to every angle and detail, losing perspective. Without healthy boundaries, it can feed an obsession with self-image,” she continues. “Occasional self-viewing is normal, but in excess it distorts self-perception. The brain can become habituated, altering how we see and judge ourselves.’”


The constant visibility of our reflections, as well as the faces we see on social media, have made a profound impact on young Jewish people in the social media age, making it easier to see themselves as Other, as well as make adjustments to their appearance with ease. 



21-year-old Maya Levine stated that they had used digital facial alteration apps like FaceTune to adjust their nose in their selfies, as well as a folder on Instagram dedicated to “nose job inspiration,” which led to an increase in  rhinoplasty content on their feed. They explained, “Over time, my feed got more and more specific, showing me content that encouraged the [thought] that I needed a smaller nose.”


Another prevalent social media trend, most commonly found on TikTok, involves users establishing facial features  in comparison to those of animals. These include, but are not limited to: Rat Face (or, “Rodent Boyfriend”), Mouse Face, Deer Face, Fox Face, Cat Face, and Bunny Face. Looking specifically at the Rat Face, or “Rodent Boyfriend” subsection of this trend, many of the examples of Rat Face are often aligned with stereotypically Jewish traits, with many  “Rodent Boyfriends” being male actors/performers with Jewish heritage (with Josh O’Connor and Timothee Chalamet at the forefront of the trend). 


The “Rodent Boyfriend” is a pet name for a man with protruding ears and a large nose, both of which are stereotypically Jewish features. Similarly, the “Rat Face” archetype is used to describe someone with a long/narrow face, as well as a straight or prominent nose. 


While not explicitly antisemitic, the  “Rodent Boyfriend” and “Rat Face” labels echo a long and damaging history of comparing Jews to rats and other vermin. This was widely used in Nazi Germany as an analogy that Jews are infesting the population with disease and must be eradicated. 


“I hated the ‘Rat Face’ [trend] because I’ve been told that I look like a rat on multiple occasions,” says twenty-one year-old Ella Braff.


TikTok and other social media platforms allow their users to talk openly about cosmetic procedures, as it’s become more and more common for influencers to share their plastic surgery journeys with their audience, under the intention of being truthful and realistic. Additionally, more and more plastic surgeons are using TikTok to reach clients, some of them with follow counts in the millions. While this is a generally positive thing, the outpour of content surrounding body and face modification is sure to have an effect on the viewer. “Plastic surgery has become so normalized–which is not an issue– but so many of the Jewish people that I know are getting nose jobs and saying, ‘Oh, best decision I ever made,’ which good for you, and I'm so happy for you, but it definitely makes me a little insecure,” said Mandell. 


While it is important to differentiate between surgical alteration and reality, as well as not glamorize these processes, many of the “Before” noses in these videos feature large, or stereotypically Jewish, noses. When one begins to see an influx of content featuring their nose–or noses similar to theirs–as something to be fixed or erased, it can increase insecurity about their natural appearance. 


“I think the openness about cosmetic surgery and seeing other people getting nose jobs and getting work done all the time makes me feel like I should,” stated Braff. 


With this all being said, there is no concrete answer as to whether or not nose jobs are becoming repopularized in Jewish communities due to social media. And while many users share content using Big Nose filters or discussing “Rat Faces,” there are also plenty of online spaces that encourage people to embrace their diverse and non-Western features.


Though rhinoplasty has roots in antisemitic physiognomy and Jewish oppression, there is no shame in deciding to undergo a rhinoplasty. The most important thing one can do for Jewish empowerment is to be visible and be proud, in whichever way one chooses. “[There’s] a mantra in my book,” states Rabbi Caryn Aviv, “that we [should] tell ourselves, ‘I am loved, I am enough and I belong.’ Those are three total contradictions to the messages we receive every day in the world, and it's a really powerful form of political resistance.”