Part III: History of the Nose Job
In 1896, Jacques Joseph performed a reconstructive operation on a young boy’s protruding ears—another feature often stereotyped as Jewish. This surgery resulted in an improved quality of life for the boy, as reported in Joseph’s notes.
Upon hearing of this operation, another young man came to see Joseph at his private practice in 1898, claiming that his large nose made him the subject of ridicule by his peers. Joseph reduced the size of the nose by chipping away at the bone. Although the young man was otherwise healthy, Joseph justified the importance of this surgery in his report for the Berlin Medical Society, stating: "The psychological effect of the Operation is of utmost importance. The depressed attitude of the patient subsided completely. He is happy to move around unnoticed. His happiness in life has increased, his wife was glad to report; the patient who formerly avoided social contact now wishes to attend and give parties. In other words, he is happy over the results."
Bur visible scarring compromised the illusion of invisibility, and according to Joseph’s findings, invisibility was the key to happiness. To address this, he performed the procedure intranasally, being the first plastic surgeon to do so. From 1904 onward, Jews could assimilate and advance within Central European society, without any permanent reminders of their “deformity.” According to reports from Joseph’s patients, Jewish men who underwent the rhinoplasty found that they could better excel in business and social ventures.
Before rhinoplasty rose to prominence, aesthetic procedures were secondary, making way for reconstructive operations during World War I. Joseph brought along his expertise in nose jobs and utilized them on soldiers whose faces became damaged in battle, refining his technique and advancing the field of facial reconstruction.
Entering the late 1920s and 30s, the illusion of safety through invisibility only lasted so long for European Jews, as the Jews found a greater danger of identification under the Third Riech. Anxiety around Jewish physiognomyescalated : both Jews and non-Jews feared being identified as Jewish, and early Nazi propaganda encouraged individuals to “weed out” the Jew, to figure out who was safe, and who was deceiving you. This fear-mongering messaging was spread through Nazi propaganda like The Poisonous Mushroom (see The History of the Jewish Nose) or “The Eternal Jew.”
“We internalize all those messages about our being Jewish from a hostile world that tell us that we're not worthy of love and care and respect,” explains Rabbi Caryn Aviv, “and that we don't belong or we won't be accepted unless we fawn or ‘people-please’ towards the dominant group…So that’s what our ancestors did: They got here and they're like, ‘Whoa, [there’s] this whole racial hierarchy [...] so let's assimilate and whiten up and let's try to pass and not draw any attention to ourselves as Jews that might target us for this anti-Jewish disgust or contempt,’ and that is internalizing anti-Jewish disgust. [...] They changed their hair color, they changed their noses, they changed their names, and they tried to pass and also leave behind lots and lots of Jewish practices that would get in the way of becoming white and moving up the economic ladder.”
In America, the nose job grew to prominence in the mid-twentieth century with the first generation of American Jews and most recent descendants of Holocaust survivors, according to Sander Gilman, who documented: “The greatest increase in the growth in rhinoplasties in the United States was in the 1940s, at a time when awareness of the dangers of being seen as a Jew was at its peak. Through the 1960s more than half of the patients seeking rhinoplasty were first- or second-generation American Jews.”
By mid-century, rhinoplasty was no longer just a tool for Jewish men seeking economic advancement, it also began to reach Jewish women, as a mode of social assimilation and to appeal to the Western ideals of desirability. Plastic surgeon Mark Gorney observed: "Patients seeking rhinoplasty ... frequently show a guilt-tinged, second-generation rejection of their ethnic background masked by excuses, such as not photographing well. Often it is not so much a desire to abandon the ethnic group as it is to be viewed as individuals and to rid themselves of specific physical attributes associated with their particular ethnic group.”
For Jewish women who possessed a hooked or large nose, their features were often labeled as unfeminine or “unsexy.” In many cases, they underwent a rhinoplasty in order to be perceived as suitable on the marriage market. This is discussed by Sarah Lucille Eichberg in her dissertation, “Bodies Of Work: Cosmetic Surgery And The Gendered Whitening Of America.” She explains, “Normative femininity is achieved only after an individual has hidden the signs of otherness.”
Jewish movie stars were also encouraged to downplay their Jewishness in order to find success in Hollywood. Thus along with the negative connotations already attributed to the nose post-Holocaust, the long-nose also didn’t ascribe to the Western beauty standard set by Hollywood. Rhinoplasty shifted from a tool of assimilation to a means of conforming to Western beauty standards established from a system of white supremacy that manifested itself in the All-American aesthetics of celebrities and prominent figures at the time.
However, around the same time that the popularity of nose jobs in Jewish communities began to peak, Funny Girl came out.
Barbra Streisand emerged as the most prominent Hollywood figure to reject invisibility, refusing to hide her Jewishness, even at the height of her career. She famously denied unwanted and unwarranted advice about her appearance, specifically her nose, in favor of putting herself, and especially her voice, first. In a 1977 Playboy interview, Streisand accredited her nose as the key to her success, rather than a setback. When asked what makes her singing voice so special, Streisand responded: “My deviated septum. If I ever had my nose fixed, it would ruin my career.”
In 1974, when shooting the cover for her album, “The Way We Were,” she found that her record label had retouched her nose, and that her iconic bump was gone. In a recent interview with TODAY, she recalled her reaction to this unfortunate and cruel incident: "It’s mine, and I said to the art director, 'If I wanted a nose job, I would have gone to a doctor. Please put the bump back.'"
Streisand’s resistance to the pressure put upon her by critics encouraged other women to embrace their big noses. Amidst the Civil Rights movement and protests against the war in Vietnam, the 60s were a revolutionary time in America for ethnic pride. This is also in line with the beginning of Second-Wave feminism, which was brought forth with the invention of the contraceptive pill.
Though both Barbra Streisand and her nose have become iconic symbols of Jewish identity, the trend of the Jewish nose job never truly died out. In many cases, it became a pattern or tradition. Generation X marks the third-generation of Jews since the Holocaust, and at this point, the nose job became a custom within Jewish families. This gave rise to the “Sweet Sixteen” nose job as a tradition in regions with a higher Jewish population.
“I see it as a Jewish ritual really. Like an inverted Bat-Mitzvah. A marking of Jewish identity through obscuring Jewish identity,” wrote Jewish author and educator Chaya Lester in an article for Hevria Magazine.
While there is no scientific evidence between a patient’s likeliness to undergo plastic surgery and their parent having plastic surgery, there are many clinics that specialize in the Mother-Daughter procedure, where both parties go under the knife at the same time, as well as instances of women getting the same nose job as their mother. Twenty-two year-old Ariela Tepperman explained that though she was initially surprised at finding out her mother underwent a nose job in the past, she opted to replicate her mother’s nose in her own procedure. “Right before [I went] into surgery,” Tepperman stated, “[my mom] told the doctor, ‘This is what she wants,’ and he examined her nose. Now we just have very small noses [...] and I'm very grateful for how it turned out.”
The third-wave of feminism, which kicked off in the mid to early 90s, also had a profound effect on plastic surgery. One of the most significant ideals brought forth by this transition was the rise of “Choice Feminism,” which expressed that the freedom of a woman’s choice is inherently feminist, because it promotes and exercises bodily autonomy within a patriarchal society.
However, the ideals of Choice Feminism have been highly debated and contested by feminist scholars and educators. In her article “Choice Feminism and the Fear of Politics,” Michaele L. Ferguson argues that Choice Feminism is anti- or unpolitical, rather than empowering: “...choice feminism offers a worldview that avoids challenging the status quo and promises inclusion for all women, regardless of their choices, and that abstains from judgment altogether.”
Both the choice to undergo plastic surgery, as well as the choice to abstain from plastic surgery, antithetically fall under the same umbrella of Choice Feminism. In “Bodies Of Work: Cosmetic Surgery And The Gendered Whitening Of America, ” Sarah Lucille Eichberg discusses the critiques of Choice Feminism as a reasoning for plastic surgery: “Male hegemony is maintained by keeping women engaged in a regime of body maintenance that supports an ideal of white, western beauty whose standards are virtually unattainable [...] Cosmetic surgery is one practice, among many, that places women in a subordinate position to men within this patriarchal politics of appearance.” She references the works of Effrat Tseelson, Naomi Wolfe, Patricia Hill Collins, Wendy Chapkiss, and Robin Lackoff and Raquel Scherr, who all argue that plastic surgery is not a feminist choice, rather it submits to the white, Western ideals of a patriarchal nation.
Examining the history of rhinoplasty reveals three significant trends of motivation; assimilation, starting from the beginning of the twentieth century and into the late 50s; aesthetic, which began in the 60s with the popularization of the nose job in celebrity culture; and culture, within Generation-X in the 80s/90s and onward.
As further evidence for these three eras (assimilation, aesthetic, and culture) of Jewish nose jobs, I will fit my own family history into these categories, starting with my great-grandmother’s nose job in 1939.