Part I: The History of the Jewish Nose





“Your nose, instead, through thick and thin,
remains between your eyes and chin,
not pasted on some other place—
be glad your nose is on your face!”
- Jack Prelutsky



Let’s paint a picture.

We look closely at the faces of two men. 

The first has a strong jaw and chiseled cheekbones. His lips are pursed in a look of anger and disdain. His eyebrows are furrowed, and his gaze is piercing. His hair is neat and fair, his  shirt is crisp , white, and collared. There is a badge clasped to his chest. He’s the picture of masculinity and nobility.

In his clenched fist is the black shirt of another man, who peers up at him with fear and cowardice. His head is wide and elongated, almost concave, and atop his scalp he’s balding, except for tufts of hair on the sides of his temples. His ears are large and protruding, his eyes open wide. His nose, just inches away from the nose of the first man, is hooked and elongated, outstretched like a beak, just grazing his upper lip. 

“The year is over, but the struggle goes on,” reads the caption in German. 

When you picture these two men, which one is the Jew?

The picture described comes from an image printed in Der Stürmer, one of the most prominent and grotesque tabloids distributing Nazi Propaganda from the 1920s to the end of World War II in 1945. But the stereotype of the “Jewish nose” didn’t originate there : it materialized in the works of thirteenth-century religious artists as a signifier of Otherness. 

Historians have shown that the so-called “Jewish nose” doesn’t actually exist; instead, this fabrication originated in medieval caricatures, which depicted Jewish people with long, hooked noses, thus creating a false pattern recognition that aligns Jewishness with the nose, and the nose as evidence of poor character. Historian Sara Lipton, author of Dark Mirror: The Medieval Origins of Anti-Jewish Iconography wrote, 


“…once people are trained to see meaning in certain shapes and forms, they may flip the process and, spurred by pre-existing assumptions, begin to see those shapes and forms where they do not, in fact, exist.”



The earliest depictions of Jews with prominent noses appeared around 1170. In  Christian art of the time, Jewish figures were often portrayed with grotesque, distorted features–likely a response to their perceived rejection of Jesus , and responsibility for his “suffering.” Early representations varied in how the nose appeared, but by the late thirteenth century, a more standardized caricature began to emerge. The long hooked nose became a visual cue used to mark Jews as Other. 

 Lipton argues that it’s true that this nose may have belonged to some Jewish people, but since the European-Jewish population was so small at the time, the new anatomical drawings that were being created to reflect an entire group of people only actually captured the features of a small number of Jewish people. As the association between a prominent nose and the Jew had already been formed, there was no use for these anatomical depictions to be contested. Even so, once somebody was identified as being Jewish, the Christian eye was trained to focus on the nose. 

Both the hooked or crooked nose, as well as the Jew, had become a symbol of sin or lack of morality. One represented the other, and vice versa. Lipton states: “Largely because of religious art, viewers came to be trained to ‘see’ significance in the noses of Jews. Eventually, the conjunction of appearance, faith, profession, and practice came to seem not just coincidental but necessary, meaningful, even ‘essential.’ By the end of the Middle Ages such ‘essentialized’ Jewish qualities as physical grossness, unlimited greed, and inherent deceitfulness were thought to apply even to members of the minority that did not share the same facial features, and a stereotype was launched.”

Towards the 19th century, the “too long” nose easily became the most identifiable feature of the Jew. This was defined as the Jew’s “nostrility,” and nostrility became a sign of character as interest toward anatomy and physiognomy grew. Thus, the “nostrility” of the Jew was synonymous with the prejudices held against the Jewish people, such as greed, untrustworthiness, and overall poor character.

Petrus Camper–an anatomist–created the nasal index, an anatomical illustration in which the nose is measured angularly in comparison with the rest of the face, to suggest a hierarchy of  racial superiority. To Camper, symmetry of the face and skull became indicative of evolutionary progress. This practice was primarily used to argue that Africans belonged to a “lesser” race due to their facial construction being comparable to those of apes. 

These ideas were applied to Jews as well. According to this graphic, the Jews shared more physical attributes with the African race rather than the Caucasian race. "It is evident to me that the Jews bear the sign of their fatherland, the Orient, throughout the world. I mean their short, black, curly hair, their brown skin color. Their rapid speech, their brusque and precipitous actions also come from this source. I believe that the Jews have more gall than other people,” stated Camper. 

However, as previously mentioned, religious art gave rise to the image of the long-nosed Jew, and it became more common as an identifier. 

In 1938, as Nazi ideology was being pushed heavily onto the people of Germany, there was a children’s book entitled The Poisonous Mushroom, informing school children about the dangers of Jews, as well as how to identify them. A quote from this book reads:  "Just as it is often very difficult to tell the poisonous from the edible mushrooms, it is often very difficult to recognize Jews as thieves and criminals..."

Children are taught to recognize the “poisonous mushrooms” by their noses. A drawing depicts the schoolchildren looking at the chalkboard, which shows the number six. The children are told that the nose of the Jew resembles that of the number six.

However, the nose proved to be an inaccurate identifier for the Jew. Joseph Jacobs and Maurice Fishberg’s Jewish Encyclopedia from the early twentieth century found that only around 20% of Jewish people possess the stereotypical long/hooked nose, and that other ethnicities possessed the long/hooked nose as well. 

Why do we see Jewish noses, even if other ethnicities possess them? It’s a case of “selective perception,” which is choosing to see the things we want–or in this case, have been conditioned–to see. William B. Helmreich expands on this in his book The Things they Say Behind your Back: “...if one thinks there is such a thing as a Jewish nose, one may take special note of it when looking at a Jew who has one while conveniently ignoring other groups, such as Arabs, who do not.”

Despite the Jewish nose being proven as a myth, the damage was done: Jewish self-perception had been tainted by generations of anti-Semitic rhetoric.

As scholar Sander Gilman writes: 

“The Jew's experience of his or her own body was so deeply impacted by anti-Semitic rhetoric that even when that body met the expectations for perfection in the community in which the Jew lived, the Jew experienced his or her body as flawed, diseased.”